Thursday, July 3, 2008

Last Post


I have made it clear from the beginning of this course that I believe strongly in gun ownership rights. In my prior estimation, the protest movement against guns was aimed at incrementally achieving the total prohibition of firearms in the United States. After the assigned readings and my own research however, I came away with a different understanding of the goals of the gun control movement. Few of their demands are radical or expressly aimed at total prohibition. On the contrary, most of their suggestions seem very rational on the surface and I believe all of them are well-intentioned. The difficult part is in finding reasonable gun laws that do not damage the integrity and intent of the Second Amendment. I do not want to get in a line-by-line argument about each particular gun control initiative like magazine capacities, .50 caliber weapons, microstamping, and others because there are many and they can all be potentially complex and lengthy debates. I would instead focus on the one I consider most agreeable (background checks) and on some of my general views of gun ownership in the United States.
One of the primary issues of the gun control movement is making registration procedures and background checks more comprehensive by closing purported loopholes such as those found at gun shows. The National Instant Criminal Background Check System (NICS) currently affects those customers who wish to purchase any firearm from a licensed, authorized dealer. However, this obviously does not encompass the private transfer or sale of firearms, which is essentially what can happen at a gun show (in addition to numerous licensed deals as well). In principal, I do not object to the intent of extending background checks to gun shows. I am not sure what implication such legislation would have on other private transfers such as a father giving a firearm as a gift to his son. Provided that background checks are relatively instantaneous (i.e. no 5 day waiting period) and do not involve additional fees, I see no problem with making personal registration a requirement.
The attempt to ban certain classes of weapon such as handguns, assault weapons, or specific types of ammunition has been a frequent -and sometimes successful- goal of the gun control movement. Much of these initiatives seem to be misguided efforts that do not target the root causes of the problem and ultimately do little to curb violence. At the very least, I would probably never agree with handgun bans for a couple reasons. First, because I am a firm believer in concealed carry laws (at least as they exist in states like Arizona) and obviously handguns are the only class suitable for such carry. For the second reason, I will quote Supreme Court Justice Scalia in his Opinion of the Court striking down Washington DC’s handgun ban last week:
“It is enough to note, as we have observed, that the American people have considered the handgun to be the quintessential self-defense weapon. There are many reasons that a citizen may prefer a handgun for home defense: It is easier to store in a location that is readily accessible in an emergency; it cannot easily be redirected or wrestled away by an attacker; it is easier to use for those without the upper-body strength to lift and aim a long gun; it can be pointed at a burglar with one hand while the other hand dials the police. Whatever the reason, handguns are the most popular weapon chosen by Americans for self-defense in the home, and a complete prohibition of their use is invalid.”
I applaud the Supreme Court’s recent decision in DC and hope that it opens the door for a better consensus on what constitutes reasonable restrictions on guns.
As it currently stands our law enforcement system is not capable of preventing illegal weapons from entering the country, regardless of what laws and bans our government enacts. As a nation, we are scarcely able to curtail marijuana production in our own states. We can’t prevent thousands of human beings from coming across our borders every year. I do not think we’ll ever be successful keeping illegal firearms out of the hands of criminals determined to obtain them. Private but semi-regulated gun ownership is a necessary option for individual citizens to protect themselves.
I believe current laws are acceptable and adequate, given correct enforcement of them. Certainly everyone recognizes that there is a violence problem in the United States and that gun deaths -both intentional and inadvertent- need to be reduced. The recent Supreme Court decision still leaves room for debate and compromise. New York City Mayor Bloomberg recently stated in the Wall Street Journal that in addition to upholding gun ownership rights, the Court decision also affirms “the constitutionality of reasonable restrictions aimed at preserving public safety and deterring criminals from acquiring and using firearms.” The million dollar question that remains is which measures are actually going to have their intended effect without compromising liberty or safety in the process.


http://www.fbi.gov/hq/cjisd/nics/index.htm
http://www.usdoj.gov/ndic/pubs21/21137/marijuana.htm
http://supct.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/07-290.ZO.html
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB121478283640414407.html?mod=opinion_main_commentaries

Friday, June 27, 2008

Text Based Assignment #4


When Gitlin says the “media changed the position of the observed”, he means that by distorting the image of the Students for a Democratic Society (SDS), it effectively appropriated their message. The media did this in two ways. The first was by “playing up” the more extreme, radical or undesirable aspects of their group, i.e. those who displayed communist or seemingly pro Viet Cong beliefs. This lead, according to Gitlin, to an influx of new members into the SDS, expecting to “find there what they saw on television or read in papers” (302). Since the media emphasized either a dumbed-down activist message or they highlighted the radical elements of its existing members, the new members consequently tended to be less intellectually sophisticated and more counter-culture in their behavior and attitudes (303).
The second way in which the media affected SDS was in the selective coverage of its various leaders. In interviews, it was common for long answers and responses by SDS leaders to be clipped and edited into just a short clip for the news (304). This allowed producers to convey whatever image about the protesters that they wanted. Consequently, leaders like Jerry Rubin and Abbie Hoffman adopted more flamboyant, attention-getting tactics and gimmicks that lent themselves to brief sound bites or news clips. This in turn led the media to follow them even more, leading to other protest leaders adopting similar tactics. The result was that much of the meaning behind their movement was lost in the distilled message. According to Gitlin, Rubin’s following “was organized precisely as a mass media audience: atomized, far-flung, episodic, [and] not politically alive” (305).
It is difficult to attempt to narrow down a protest movement that has been most affected by media coverage. Certainly with recent issues opposition to the Iraq War the media has played a central role in how the issue is framed. Much of one’s opinion about the current situation in Iraq tends to hinge on the preferred news source. If someone was watching Fox News in the months following the 2003 invasion, he may have had a more positive view of the prosecution of the war. That is one of the major charges by people like Robert Greenwald in his documentary Outfoxed. On the other hand, someone choosing to watch CNN or MSNBC may derive a more pessimistic view of the situation in Iraq. The perception of whether “feel good” stories coming out of there are contrived or underreported is largely based on what news outlet one chooses.
With the major mainstream success of the film An Inconvenient Truth, certainly the environmental movement has found added ammo for its cause. The meteoric rise in gas prices has served to hit Americans in the wallet as an added reminder to the dangers of wasteful energy policies. One interesting and recent response trend I’ve noticed among corporations is to try and convey and publicize an image of being friendly to the planet. Particularly among those industries that are most frequently criticized, namely the oil/energy companies and automobile manufacturers, there is a tendency to try and recast themselves as committed to making a real and concerted effort to go green. I’ve seen the commercials over the last few months and I’ve noticed the change in websites for companies like BP, Shell, and various automakers touting their efforts to make a difference. Time will tell if their efforts are genuine or a nod toward public relations.

Opinion Assignment #4


Naomi Klein is correct when she says that the modern forms of protest are less dangerous than earlier, more “radical” forms of demonstration. The internet and blogging allow for people all over the world to communicate and share their ideas but it also lends itself to a more hands-off, detached form of protest. Giant charity concerts carry little of the dangers of marches or strikes and often their message is lost in the shadow of the event. However, when Klein and others in “The Bono-ization of Activism” suggest that such modern methods are less powerful, they miss the mark.
The key differences between activism today and yesteryear lie in advancing technology and a shifting role of the media. Technology and mass-communication in particular is on a completely different level today than what it was even 20 years ago. The internet, satellite communications, microchips, and cellular phones are now the standard. Together, they have changed and are continuing to change the way we shop (Amazon, Ebay), the way we do business (email, video conferencing), the way we fight wars (un-manned aircraft, “smart bombs”) and the way we communicate with friends and family (Myspace, text messaging). It should come as no surprise then that the ways we protest (such as blogs or Youtube) have also become more distant or hands-off with more sophisticated technology.
Certainly there are some valid criticisms of the internet as a tool for activism. For example, it is far too easy to filter out or avoid if one doesn’t “buy into” the message. It lacks the intrusive, in-your-face presence of a protest. As such, it often ends up finding ears on those who are already sympathetic to the cause, not actually creating new converts. Klein may also be right when she says that it is “safer to mouth off in a blog than put your body on the line” (1).
However, evaluating one’s effective contribution to a cause is not as simple. Just because people are not out actively getting clubbed or tear-gassed on the street does not mean that they are not making an impact. Contribution cannot be judged by proximity to danger or number of bruises incurred. The ability of online forums, blogs, and activist sites to organize people is unparalleled. Supporters can meet new people around the world, share news and information and become energized by their numbers into taking more direct action on the street. In many cases, this results in the actual physical manifestations of protest that Klein so cherishes. One only need look at the relative success of little known 2008 Presidential candidate Ron Paul, whose rabid, internet-based support translated into numerous local organizers and fundraising that often surpassed his more prominent peers.
Criticizing concerts such as Live Aid (seriously, how cool is this?) as being politically ineffectual seems very narrow-minded. Frankly if only 1% of people came away with any increased consciousness from that concert, it was still a significant contribution to ending hunger in Ethiopia. Somehow I doubt that Naomi Klein or “Susie” (from the same CNN article) could think of a method to raise $140 million dollars for a relatively obscure East African nation. Last time I checked, money is what drives almost all political change in most areas of the world. Klein can bemoan the evil consumerism of such fund-raising tactics but certainly not their efficacy. Lance Armstrong’s Livestrong foundation has raised $181 million for cancer awareness, largely through the sale of glorified, yellow rubber bands.
Like Klein, I’m sure we all wish that most people could individually and spontaneously volunteer their time and money to various causes without the endorsement of a philanthropic billionaire or a line-up of rock stars. However, calling their effectiveness into question because they do not also confront Klein’s particular enemy (globalization/capitalism) comes off as petty.

Thursday, June 26, 2008

Supreme Court rules DC handgun ban unconstitutional


In the gun control debate, today's 5-4 decision by the Supreme Court to overturn Washington DC's 32 year old ban on handguns is monumental. NRA President Wayne LaPierre has already promised that similar lawsuits to overturn restrictive gun laws will follow in other areas like Chicago and San Francisco. I will be very curious to see if this has any impact on DC's notoriously high crime rate.




Monday, June 23, 2008

No concealed weapons on campus - at least this year


Once again, this news is actually a month old but I only found out about it recently. It caused some controversy at ASU earlier this year when State Senator Karen Johnson proposed a bill that would allow teachers and students with concealed carry permits to bring their firearms on campus. Well apparently, the bill met its demise in the State Senate last month as it was blocked from going to a full vote by Senate President Tim Bee. According to the Arizona Republic, the vote died for one of two reasons. The first theory is that Bee killed the bill because it would have been unlikely to get enough votes to pass. The second (as voiced by Sen. Johnson) is that "many lawmakers, facing re-election races this fall, had pressured Bee to kill the bill so they wouldn't have to take a position on such a controversial issue." Frankly, I'm inclined to believe the latter. Hurray democracy.


Friday, June 20, 2008

Opinion Assignment #3


There is a time and place for almost everything and “radical” protest tactics are no different. What is deemed appropriate or acceptable should be decided on a case-by-case basis and the goals of a movement. Sidewalk counseling, the Clothesline project, and “outing” are all uncomfortable but acceptable methods to employ but on different conditions.
Sidewalk counseling is a tactic I have nothing against so long as it’s done in a peaceful manner. It is a bit intrusive and potentially emotionally damaging to the women heading to clinics but a completed procedure is also emotionally damaging to the people that consider abortion to be murder. For them, counseling is seen as a last resort option to prevent death. No matter what your views on abortion are, it is a decision that deserves careful and deliberate thought. Sidewalk counseling -unsolicited though it may be- can be another part of a woman’s decision-making process. Frankly if a woman can’t walk past these counselors and protestors unfazed, I tend to think that an abortion is something she’s not emotionally or mentally prepared for. Sidewalk counseling is certainly contentious but as long it’s done with discretion and compassion, I do not see the harm.
The Clothesline project and “outing” are both acceptable because they aim to encourage dialogue around issues that much of the public is silent on. The main problem I have with these tactics of “calling people out” lies in the potential for abuse or mistaken labeling. Falsely accusing someone of being a homosexual or a rapist can destroy a reputation or a career. To some extent, I think this danger is mitigated by the potential for libel or slander lawsuits from the accused. In addition, I think these groups will have a tendency to self-regulate in favor of good taste and judgment, especially among activist groups which seek to maintain their credibility and their supporters.
All of the aforementioned tactics (in addition to the actions of ACT UP) are deemed radical because they are intrusive, persistent, and attention-grabbing for their flamboyance. For the same reasons, they are very controversial and they attract a lot of criticism. Since these “radical” forms of protest have proven so successful in their ability to grab attention, the question then comes as to whether they will become more common place with other groups. Certainly the wide application of disruptive tactics by most protest organizations would lead to a state of borderline chaos. To address any potentials of such “radical” protest forms becoming out of hand, I would say there’s a natural human tendency to not “rock the boat” unless an issue is extremely pressing. I don’t believe that tactics like ACT UP dressing in costumes, sneaking into buildings and Republican conventions to disrupt them and spread their message will ever be very widespread or common. It takes a certain kind of commitment and militancy that many people simply do not possess until they are pushed hard enough.

I suppose what I am talking about is also encapsulated in the phrase “desperate times call for desperate measures”. Radical measures will never be widely adopted by the majority of activists unless their particular issue has reached a boiling point. In a sense, what I am saying is that these tactics become acceptable when a significant number of activists are willing to employ them. The cost of inaction has outweighed the ostracism they may face for their tactics. In the case of ACT UP, the gay community could no longer quietly tolerate watching thousands of Americans literally wither away while their government and society stood by, oblivious of the growing crisis. As Maxine Wolfe put it in her interview, “We were trying to save our own lives and the lives of people we knew” (Somella 6). Like the pro-lifers who try to stop women from entering abortion clinics, the matter is perceived as a life or death threat where all other options have been exhausted.

Wednesday, June 18, 2008

Mass Stabbing in Japan



This news is a couple weeks old but I found it interesting in a country that has virtually no privately owned firearms. So apparently some crazy gent who was "tired of living" drove a truck into a crowd of people in a district of Tokyo and started knifing people. This isn't the first time something like this has happened in Japan either. I guess what I took from this story is that a motivated psychopath can kill a lot of people without the aid of a gun.