Naomi Klein is correct when she says that the modern forms of protest are less dangerous than earlier, more “radical” forms of demonstration. The internet and blogging allow for people all over the world to communicate and share their ideas but it also lends itself to a more hands-off, detached form of protest. Giant charity concerts carry little of the dangers of marches or strikes and often their message is lost in the shadow of the event. However, when Klein and others in “The Bono-ization of Activism” suggest that such modern methods are less powerful, they miss the mark.
The key differences between activism today and yesteryear lie in advancing technology and a shifting role of the media. Technology and mass-communication in particular is on a completely different level today than what it was even 20 years ago. The internet, satellite communications, microchips, and cellular phones are now the standard. Together, they have changed and are continuing to change the way we shop (Amazon, Ebay), the way we do business (email, video conferencing), the way we fight wars (un-manned aircraft, “smart bombs”) and the way we communicate with friends and family (Myspace, text messaging). It should come as no surprise then that the ways we protest (such as blogs or Youtube) have also become more distant or hands-off with more sophisticated technology.
Certainly there are some valid criticisms of the internet as a tool for activism. For example, it is far too easy to filter out or avoid if one doesn’t “buy into” the message. It lacks the intrusive, in-your-face presence of a protest. As such, it often ends up finding ears on those who are already sympathetic to the cause, not actually creating new converts. Klein may also be right when she says that it is “safer to mouth off in a blog than put your body on the line” (1).
However, evaluating one’s effective contribution to a cause is not as simple. Just because people are not out actively getting clubbed or tear-gassed on the street does not mean that they are not making an impact. Contribution cannot be judged by proximity to danger or number of bruises incurred. The ability of online forums, blogs, and activist sites to organize people is unparalleled. Supporters can meet new people around the world, share news and information and become energized by their numbers into taking more direct action on the street. In many cases, this results in the actual physical manifestations of protest that Klein so cherishes. One only need look at the relative success of little known 2008 Presidential candidate Ron Paul, whose rabid, internet-based support translated into numerous local organizers and fundraising that often surpassed his more prominent peers.
Criticizing concerts such as Live Aid (seriously, how cool is this?) as being politically ineffectual seems very narrow-minded. Frankly if only 1% of people came away with any increased consciousness from that concert, it was still a significant contribution to ending hunger in Ethiopia. Somehow I doubt that Naomi Klein or “Susie” (from the same CNN article) could think of a method to raise $140 million dollars for a relatively obscure East African nation. Last time I checked, money is what drives almost all political change in most areas of the world. Klein can bemoan the evil consumerism of such fund-raising tactics but certainly not their efficacy. Lance Armstrong’s Livestrong foundation has raised $181 million for cancer awareness, largely through the sale of glorified, yellow rubber bands.
Like Klein, I’m sure we all wish that most people could individually and spontaneously volunteer their time and money to various causes without the endorsement of a philanthropic billionaire or a line-up of rock stars. However, calling their effectiveness into question because they do not also confront Klein’s particular enemy (globalization/capitalism) comes off as petty.
The key differences between activism today and yesteryear lie in advancing technology and a shifting role of the media. Technology and mass-communication in particular is on a completely different level today than what it was even 20 years ago. The internet, satellite communications, microchips, and cellular phones are now the standard. Together, they have changed and are continuing to change the way we shop (Amazon, Ebay), the way we do business (email, video conferencing), the way we fight wars (un-manned aircraft, “smart bombs”) and the way we communicate with friends and family (Myspace, text messaging). It should come as no surprise then that the ways we protest (such as blogs or Youtube) have also become more distant or hands-off with more sophisticated technology.
Certainly there are some valid criticisms of the internet as a tool for activism. For example, it is far too easy to filter out or avoid if one doesn’t “buy into” the message. It lacks the intrusive, in-your-face presence of a protest. As such, it often ends up finding ears on those who are already sympathetic to the cause, not actually creating new converts. Klein may also be right when she says that it is “safer to mouth off in a blog than put your body on the line” (1).
However, evaluating one’s effective contribution to a cause is not as simple. Just because people are not out actively getting clubbed or tear-gassed on the street does not mean that they are not making an impact. Contribution cannot be judged by proximity to danger or number of bruises incurred. The ability of online forums, blogs, and activist sites to organize people is unparalleled. Supporters can meet new people around the world, share news and information and become energized by their numbers into taking more direct action on the street. In many cases, this results in the actual physical manifestations of protest that Klein so cherishes. One only need look at the relative success of little known 2008 Presidential candidate Ron Paul, whose rabid, internet-based support translated into numerous local organizers and fundraising that often surpassed his more prominent peers.
Criticizing concerts such as Live Aid (seriously, how cool is this?) as being politically ineffectual seems very narrow-minded. Frankly if only 1% of people came away with any increased consciousness from that concert, it was still a significant contribution to ending hunger in Ethiopia. Somehow I doubt that Naomi Klein or “Susie” (from the same CNN article) could think of a method to raise $140 million dollars for a relatively obscure East African nation. Last time I checked, money is what drives almost all political change in most areas of the world. Klein can bemoan the evil consumerism of such fund-raising tactics but certainly not their efficacy. Lance Armstrong’s Livestrong foundation has raised $181 million for cancer awareness, largely through the sale of glorified, yellow rubber bands.
Like Klein, I’m sure we all wish that most people could individually and spontaneously volunteer their time and money to various causes without the endorsement of a philanthropic billionaire or a line-up of rock stars. However, calling their effectiveness into question because they do not also confront Klein’s particular enemy (globalization/capitalism) comes off as petty.

3 comments:
Jared--
I loved your postings this week, particularly because you did a terrific job incorporating links and multi-media into them. The Queen clip rocks. It's horrible that Freddie Mercury passed away so early. I have tried again to enable the "view my grades" feature in Blackboard. If you can't see them there, let me know. Best. --Francine
You make a great point that writers like Klein seem to ignore; the the effectiveness of today's web-based or 'consumerist' protesting cannot be ignored. Fund-raising and awareness have taken on new levels of effectiveness thanks to modern technology, and anyone who discounts this should reconsider.
My only question would be; could this effectiveness be translated into real action? What do you think it'd take for that to occur?
Brian,
Sadly I think millions of dollars are one of the only things these days that translates into "real action". I consider funding and organizing charity events or designing products to raise awareness/money to be real action. Whether the funds are appropriately distributed to the right governmental organizations/NGOs/charities to effect change on the ground is another matter.
Post a Comment