Friday, June 20, 2008

Opinion Assignment #3


There is a time and place for almost everything and “radical” protest tactics are no different. What is deemed appropriate or acceptable should be decided on a case-by-case basis and the goals of a movement. Sidewalk counseling, the Clothesline project, and “outing” are all uncomfortable but acceptable methods to employ but on different conditions.
Sidewalk counseling is a tactic I have nothing against so long as it’s done in a peaceful manner. It is a bit intrusive and potentially emotionally damaging to the women heading to clinics but a completed procedure is also emotionally damaging to the people that consider abortion to be murder. For them, counseling is seen as a last resort option to prevent death. No matter what your views on abortion are, it is a decision that deserves careful and deliberate thought. Sidewalk counseling -unsolicited though it may be- can be another part of a woman’s decision-making process. Frankly if a woman can’t walk past these counselors and protestors unfazed, I tend to think that an abortion is something she’s not emotionally or mentally prepared for. Sidewalk counseling is certainly contentious but as long it’s done with discretion and compassion, I do not see the harm.
The Clothesline project and “outing” are both acceptable because they aim to encourage dialogue around issues that much of the public is silent on. The main problem I have with these tactics of “calling people out” lies in the potential for abuse or mistaken labeling. Falsely accusing someone of being a homosexual or a rapist can destroy a reputation or a career. To some extent, I think this danger is mitigated by the potential for libel or slander lawsuits from the accused. In addition, I think these groups will have a tendency to self-regulate in favor of good taste and judgment, especially among activist groups which seek to maintain their credibility and their supporters.
All of the aforementioned tactics (in addition to the actions of ACT UP) are deemed radical because they are intrusive, persistent, and attention-grabbing for their flamboyance. For the same reasons, they are very controversial and they attract a lot of criticism. Since these “radical” forms of protest have proven so successful in their ability to grab attention, the question then comes as to whether they will become more common place with other groups. Certainly the wide application of disruptive tactics by most protest organizations would lead to a state of borderline chaos. To address any potentials of such “radical” protest forms becoming out of hand, I would say there’s a natural human tendency to not “rock the boat” unless an issue is extremely pressing. I don’t believe that tactics like ACT UP dressing in costumes, sneaking into buildings and Republican conventions to disrupt them and spread their message will ever be very widespread or common. It takes a certain kind of commitment and militancy that many people simply do not possess until they are pushed hard enough.

I suppose what I am talking about is also encapsulated in the phrase “desperate times call for desperate measures”. Radical measures will never be widely adopted by the majority of activists unless their particular issue has reached a boiling point. In a sense, what I am saying is that these tactics become acceptable when a significant number of activists are willing to employ them. The cost of inaction has outweighed the ostracism they may face for their tactics. In the case of ACT UP, the gay community could no longer quietly tolerate watching thousands of Americans literally wither away while their government and society stood by, oblivious of the growing crisis. As Maxine Wolfe put it in her interview, “We were trying to save our own lives and the lives of people we knew” (Somella 6). Like the pro-lifers who try to stop women from entering abortion clinics, the matter is perceived as a life or death threat where all other options have been exhausted.

1 comment:

mike partain said...

Jared, I’m not going to lie you’ve written one of the best blogs I’ve read in class. You include multimedia to keep us interested, you present your views thoughtfully, they are supported by your opinion and research and your structure and flow allows for easy understanding of any subject you’ve written on. I’ve recently been a victim of slander in my cities local newspaper for something job related and although its not anything like being “outed” I can attest to the fact that having no control over your image and having people pass judgment based on a one sided un-researched newspaper article has been the most trying time in my life. I understand radical protest is necessary but damage to an innocent persons reputation is not, thanks for the thoughtful post.