When Gitlin says the “media changed the position of the observed”, he means that by distorting the image of the Students for a Democratic Society (SDS), it effectively appropriated their message. The media did this in two ways. The first was by “playing up” the more extreme, radical or undesirable aspects of their group, i.e. those who displayed communist or seemingly pro Viet Cong beliefs. This lead, according to Gitlin, to an influx of new members into the SDS, expecting to “find there what they saw on television or read in papers” (302). Since the media emphasized either a dumbed-down activist message or they highlighted the radical elements of its existing members, the new members consequently tended to be less intellectually sophisticated and more counter-culture in their behavior and attitudes (303).
The second way in which the media affected SDS was in the selective coverage of its various leaders. In interviews, it was common for long answers and responses by SDS leaders to be clipped and edited into just a short clip for the news (304). This allowed producers to convey whatever image about the protesters that they wanted. Consequently, leaders like Jerry Rubin and Abbie Hoffman adopted more flamboyant, attention-getting tactics and gimmicks that lent themselves to brief sound bites or news clips. This in turn led the media to follow them even more, leading to other protest leaders adopting similar tactics. The result was that much of the meaning behind their movement was lost in the distilled message. According to Gitlin, Rubin’s following “was organized precisely as a mass media audience: atomized, far-flung, episodic, [and] not politically alive” (305).
It is difficult to attempt to narrow down a protest movement that has been most affected by media coverage. Certainly with recent issues opposition to the Iraq War the media has played a central role in how the issue is framed. Much of one’s opinion about the current situation in Iraq tends to hinge on the preferred news source. If someone was watching Fox News in the months following the 2003 invasion, he may have had a more positive view of the prosecution of the war. That is one of the major charges by people like Robert Greenwald in his documentary Outfoxed. On the other hand, someone choosing to watch CNN or MSNBC may derive a more pessimistic view of the situation in Iraq. The perception of whether “feel good” stories coming out of there are contrived or underreported is largely based on what news outlet one chooses.
With the major mainstream success of the film An Inconvenient Truth, certainly the environmental movement has found added ammo for its cause. The meteoric rise in gas prices has served to hit Americans in the wallet as an added reminder to the dangers of wasteful energy policies. One interesting and recent response trend I’ve noticed among corporations is to try and convey and publicize an image of being friendly to the planet. Particularly among those industries that are most frequently criticized, namely the oil/energy companies and automobile manufacturers, there is a tendency to try and recast themselves as committed to making a real and concerted effort to go green. I’ve seen the commercials over the last few months and I’ve noticed the change in websites for companies like BP, Shell, and various automakers touting their efforts to make a difference. Time will tell if their efforts are genuine or a nod toward public relations.
The second way in which the media affected SDS was in the selective coverage of its various leaders. In interviews, it was common for long answers and responses by SDS leaders to be clipped and edited into just a short clip for the news (304). This allowed producers to convey whatever image about the protesters that they wanted. Consequently, leaders like Jerry Rubin and Abbie Hoffman adopted more flamboyant, attention-getting tactics and gimmicks that lent themselves to brief sound bites or news clips. This in turn led the media to follow them even more, leading to other protest leaders adopting similar tactics. The result was that much of the meaning behind their movement was lost in the distilled message. According to Gitlin, Rubin’s following “was organized precisely as a mass media audience: atomized, far-flung, episodic, [and] not politically alive” (305).
It is difficult to attempt to narrow down a protest movement that has been most affected by media coverage. Certainly with recent issues opposition to the Iraq War the media has played a central role in how the issue is framed. Much of one’s opinion about the current situation in Iraq tends to hinge on the preferred news source. If someone was watching Fox News in the months following the 2003 invasion, he may have had a more positive view of the prosecution of the war. That is one of the major charges by people like Robert Greenwald in his documentary Outfoxed. On the other hand, someone choosing to watch CNN or MSNBC may derive a more pessimistic view of the situation in Iraq. The perception of whether “feel good” stories coming out of there are contrived or underreported is largely based on what news outlet one chooses.
With the major mainstream success of the film An Inconvenient Truth, certainly the environmental movement has found added ammo for its cause. The meteoric rise in gas prices has served to hit Americans in the wallet as an added reminder to the dangers of wasteful energy policies. One interesting and recent response trend I’ve noticed among corporations is to try and convey and publicize an image of being friendly to the planet. Particularly among those industries that are most frequently criticized, namely the oil/energy companies and automobile manufacturers, there is a tendency to try and recast themselves as committed to making a real and concerted effort to go green. I’ve seen the commercials over the last few months and I’ve noticed the change in websites for companies like BP, Shell, and various automakers touting their efforts to make a difference. Time will tell if their efforts are genuine or a nod toward public relations.

