Friday, June 6, 2008

Opinion Based Assignment #1

Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X were both hugely influential members of the black community and champions of civil rights and equality throughout the 1950s and 1960s. However, the two quickly differentiated themselves along ideological about how best to effect change for their people. Whereas Dr. King represented the non-violent approach popularized by Gandhi, Malcolm adopted a fiery rhetoric that was both confrontational and polarizing. Yet, as author Claybourne Carson points out, each man was ultimately still striving for the same goal to raise public awareness and end the centuries-long tradition of discrimination in the United States. Though their approaches were very different and attracted different followers and attention, they each made an invaluable contribution to the civil rights movement in their own way.
Dr. King’s beliefs are very much informed by religion and his fundamental belief that all men are entitled to certain rights by God. In his “Letter from a Birmingham Jail”, Dr. King says these rights derive from what he calls moral law or that which “uplifts human personality” (1). His belief is that since the segregation laws of the time were degrading to human personality, it was therefore his God-given right and duty to disobey them. His approach is one of nonviolent protest because he believes it takes a stronger man to set an example, to stand up for something without degrading oneself by resorting to violence. Furthermore he believes in all of humanity as a brotherhood with the ability to coexist. The burning of bridges through polarizing speech or incitement to violence would only damage the possibility of achieving that goal.
There are certainly some advantages to Malcolm X’s early approach. Not everyone fully understands or responds well to the nonviolent method. People can see it as ineffective or lacking the appeal of confrontation - what author Carson calls the “excitement and emotional satisfaction…[of] revenge and retaliation” - (2). For the downtrodden lower class African Americans of the time, Malcolm X’s message of racial pride was uplifting and motivating, especially among youth. His confrontational approach tapped into the bitter emotions that they were feeling. The Black Panthers used much the same tactic of appealing to racial pride and a duty to defend oneself to great success in its recruiting efforts.
The two different approaches are reconcilable as Carson argues. However, this is not simply because both Malcolm X and Dr. King understood and agreed with some of the same principles, it is because the two approaches combined succeed in mobilizing the greatest number of people possible. Individuals are moved to act or react in different ways. The anti-Vietnam movement was hardly a homogeneous or cohesive effort. It was a rag tag collection of groups with different ideals and methods but with the same bottom line: end the war and bring the troops back. So long as the more so called “violent” approach is the kind which Dr. King criticized as being “verbal combat” without much real consequence, it should be welcomed because it’s encouraging more dialogue and more diverse participation(2). It is appealing to different bases and still getting the message out. Real violence as a means to create change should always be a last resort.
Yet Malcolm’s approach (at least in rhetoric) is ultimately limited because it is not a position of realism. Dr. King understood that Malcolm and the Nation of Islam’s advocacy of black separatism was not a tenable position within the U.S. King’s was a position of compromise and reconciliation because he knew that the two societies (white and black) inhabit the same space and must therefore learn to coexist.
As the author indicates, if Malcolm and Dr. King had lived longer, they would have perhaps grown to appreciate or even adopt some of each other’s beliefs to a greater extent. For Malcolm, it may have been a more tempered approach that recognized the need ultimately to coexist. For Dr. King it may have been a greater appreciation for the motivating, mobilizing power of Black Nationalism.

(1) King Jr., Martin Luther. “Letter from a Birmingham Jail”. Page 4
(2) Carson, Claybourne. “The Unfinished Dialogue of Martin Luther King, Jr. and Malcolm X”. Pages 16, 19.

No comments: