To start with my ultimate icon for the modern women’s rights movement, I cannot possibly imagine anything but a woman as an effective figurehead. A male would be met with a skeptical eye by females and a comical one by other men. Someone who came from a rough or unprivileged background would probably carry more legitimacy in the public’s eye. Someone who was raised in the upper class would not be able to connect as well when trying talk about victimization and oppression.
Having a woman from a minority race who could draw on parallel experiences of racism would be beneficial as well. This is not only because of the under-explored concept of intersectionality which Kimberle Crenshaw explores as the qualitatively different discrimination that women of color experience, it could also serve to widen the sympathetic audience. Racism is an issue that easily finds eager ears in this country while sexism is talked about much less frequently.
Age is also an important factor as too young of a woman would be perceived to lack the maturity and experience to be the head of the movement. At the same times, she can’t appear too old so as to seem out of touch (just look at John McCain’s campaign). I imagine that the ideal candidate would be in her late 30s to early 40s so as to appear reasonably youthful while still possessing the wisdom of an adult woman. Having a woman with religious convictions would probably be beneficial in drawing support from other believers. Historically, the church (in most religious traditions) has been largely responsible for the perpetuation of female subservience and patriarchy in society. Dissent to social feminist reform -as seen in Young’s documentation of Mormon resistance to the ERA- will often come from conservative women raised in a religious tradition. A woman, who supports the beliefs of feminism, while at the same time espousing a belief in God, will be able to reach the most people.
An iconic figure possesses some outstanding quality that draws people to the movement. Generally it’s charisma but sometimes it is just a dogged determination or stoic principles that earn respect and followers. Frankly it also gives a public with a notoriously short attention span one esteemed person who provides them with the basic introduction to a movement. It is far less likely that the masses will seek to inform themselves on a topic by reading mission statements and manifestos without some credible spokesperson or figurehead who first grabs their attention. The potential downside lies in staking so much of a movement’s image on one icon that -as a human being- is not infallible. If one person is the pillar or foundation of a movement, then he is a single point of failure for everything to come crashing down if his personal image becomes tainted. If that icon was discovered to be involved in some sort of scandal, it would undermine the followers of the movement almost as much as the disgraced icon himself.
Image is undoubtedly a powerful thing in this day and age. Unfortunately, it sometimes trumps content and character. Packaging and presentation are very important if one wants to convey a message to the maximum number of people. Companies do it when they want to market a product and activists need to consider it when they elect a spokesperson. The wrong person can end up turning people away from a movement or prevent it from being taken seriously.
Claudette Colvin undoubtedly would not have made the same impact that Rosa Parks did for three reasons which author Hendrickson mentions: she was young, emotional, and had a rumored “unsavory” reputation. By contrast Rosa Parks was mature, composed, respected, and completely unthreatening. She was active in church as well as the beginnings of the Civil Rights Movement. She thus had strong ties with and support from the black and religious communities. She had both the qualifications and the image to reach the largest audience possible. Having a boisterous teenager with a questionable reputation and background as figurehead would have undermined the credibility of the Montgomery Bus Boycott in the eyes of many whites and blacks alike.
Having a woman from a minority race who could draw on parallel experiences of racism would be beneficial as well. This is not only because of the under-explored concept of intersectionality which Kimberle Crenshaw explores as the qualitatively different discrimination that women of color experience, it could also serve to widen the sympathetic audience. Racism is an issue that easily finds eager ears in this country while sexism is talked about much less frequently.
Age is also an important factor as too young of a woman would be perceived to lack the maturity and experience to be the head of the movement. At the same times, she can’t appear too old so as to seem out of touch (just look at John McCain’s campaign). I imagine that the ideal candidate would be in her late 30s to early 40s so as to appear reasonably youthful while still possessing the wisdom of an adult woman. Having a woman with religious convictions would probably be beneficial in drawing support from other believers. Historically, the church (in most religious traditions) has been largely responsible for the perpetuation of female subservience and patriarchy in society. Dissent to social feminist reform -as seen in Young’s documentation of Mormon resistance to the ERA- will often come from conservative women raised in a religious tradition. A woman, who supports the beliefs of feminism, while at the same time espousing a belief in God, will be able to reach the most people.
An iconic figure possesses some outstanding quality that draws people to the movement. Generally it’s charisma but sometimes it is just a dogged determination or stoic principles that earn respect and followers. Frankly it also gives a public with a notoriously short attention span one esteemed person who provides them with the basic introduction to a movement. It is far less likely that the masses will seek to inform themselves on a topic by reading mission statements and manifestos without some credible spokesperson or figurehead who first grabs their attention. The potential downside lies in staking so much of a movement’s image on one icon that -as a human being- is not infallible. If one person is the pillar or foundation of a movement, then he is a single point of failure for everything to come crashing down if his personal image becomes tainted. If that icon was discovered to be involved in some sort of scandal, it would undermine the followers of the movement almost as much as the disgraced icon himself.
Image is undoubtedly a powerful thing in this day and age. Unfortunately, it sometimes trumps content and character. Packaging and presentation are very important if one wants to convey a message to the maximum number of people. Companies do it when they want to market a product and activists need to consider it when they elect a spokesperson. The wrong person can end up turning people away from a movement or prevent it from being taken seriously.
Claudette Colvin undoubtedly would not have made the same impact that Rosa Parks did for three reasons which author Hendrickson mentions: she was young, emotional, and had a rumored “unsavory” reputation. By contrast Rosa Parks was mature, composed, respected, and completely unthreatening. She was active in church as well as the beginnings of the Civil Rights Movement. She thus had strong ties with and support from the black and religious communities. She had both the qualifications and the image to reach the largest audience possible. Having a boisterous teenager with a questionable reputation and background as figurehead would have undermined the credibility of the Montgomery Bus Boycott in the eyes of many whites and blacks alike.

No comments:
Post a Comment