Friday, June 6, 2008

Text Based Assignment #1


The United States has had a uniquely robust gun culture throughout its relatively short history. We are after all, a nation formed by hardened frontiersmen who used armed resistance to gain independence from British tyranny. More than 200 years later however, America’s gun culture has become a contentious issue. The U.S. has one of the highest murder rates per capita among developed countries. The annual publication Small Arms Survey estimates that the U.S. is now home to nearly half of the world’s civilian-owned guns(1).
It is difficult to pinpoint major events in the development of the gun control movement. Certainly the United States’ conspicuously high murder rate has served as a constant reminder of the unresolved firearms issue and organized gun control groups have been lobbying for tighter control since the 1970s. The major political pushes for tighter gun legislation in other Western nations tend to come in the wake of high profile assassinations or mass shootings. In the United Kingdom, it was the Dunblane massacre at an elementary school while in Australia it was the massacre of 35 tourists in Port Arthur, Tasmania which sparked controversy and ultimately resulted in a major overhaul of existing gun ownership laws in both countries.
The United States has had its share of high profile shootings that have all brought the gun control debate back to the forefront of the public consciousness. The failed assassination of Ronald Reagan in 1981 resulted in the permanent paralysis of his press secretary James Brady. Together with wife Sarah, they have since become leading activists in the push to restrict the availability of assault weapons(2). The wild North Hollywood gun battle in 1997 which ensued after a bank robbery gone bad did much to reaffirm the dangerous image of assault rifles in the public mind. Since the early 1990’s a steady stream of school shootings such as the tragedy at Columbine High School in Colorado have been a driving force behind calls for greater legislation. The latest round of public debate comes on the heels of the most recent school shootings at Virginia Tech and Northern Illinois University.
The National Council to Control Handguns (NCCH) and the National Coalition to Ban Handguns were each formed in 1974. Over time, the two organizations have changed their names (from NCCH to the Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence and from NCBH to Coalition to Stop Gun Violence) as well as some of their objectives to now concentrate primarily on restriction of assault weapons and closer monitoring of weapon sales at local gun shows. Neither achieved much of note until the Brady Bill (required waiting periods on handgun purchases) and the Federal Assault Weapons Ban were signed into effect in 1994. Both successes were short-lived though as each measure has since expired without renewal. Gun control movement has stagnated a bit since then and gun laws have become a more localized, state matter.

-------------------------------------------------------------

The mass society theory does not explain the gun control movement or its motives because I don’t think the campaigners are searching for a sense of community though the issue, their pre-existing sense of community is what has led them to speak up in the first place. They come from law enforcement professionals, religious groups, teachers and students concerned about safety at their schools or workplace, as well as from the bereaved family and friends who have lost a loved one to gun violence.
There have certainly been some cultural changes over America’s history that have given strength to the gun control movement. As authors Goodwin and Jasper point out, the move away from a more rural, subsistence agriculture society was crucial to the growth of the animal rights movement because a more urban, industrial society does not rely on animals as tools and food for daily survival(3). In the same way, urbanization and the industrial revolution have also led to changing ideas on the role of the firearm in American society. The wild frontier patrolled by warrior tribes no longer exists. Few Americans must hunt for food to ensure their own survival. The idea of armed overthrow of the government is nearly unfathomable.
The unprecedented access to lethal weaponry makes the prospect of more mass shooting a very real and scary possibility. Firearms technology has progressed to a deadly art form that has created weapons far more lethally efficient than their Revolutionary War predecessors. It is certainly plausible that the Founding Fathers did not foresee the mass proliferation of assault weapons currently available. Today it is not only more likely that someone will become psychologically overwhelmed by the fast-paced modern world but that he will have the capability to kill literally dozens of people in a matter of minutes if he snaps.

(1) “Small Arms Survey 2007: Guns and the City”. http://www.smallarmssurvey.org/
(2) http://www.bradycampaign.org/about/
(3) Goodwin, Jeff and James Jasper. The Social Movements Reader. Malden: Blackwell Publishing, 2003.

No comments: